Access to Energy

THE LETDOWN

After all this praise, the letdown: The fundamental trouble with the electric car is its inability to store much energy. Per unit weight or volume, a battery can hold nowhere near as much energy as a tankful of fuel¾per unit weight, even special batteries hold about 500 times less. The most advanced batteries (not yet on the market) can do about 5 times better¾which makes them only 100 times worse than a tankful of gasoline. At 10% efficiency of the gasoline engine (compared to over 90% of the electric motor) that still means a nasty choice between 100 lbs of lead-acid battery or 8 gallons of gasoline for the same load to be transported through the same distance.

Second, what little energy a battery does hold, it can neither accept nor release very quickly: Its power density, as well as its energy density, is low.

To which add that today's batteries don't last long under EV driving conditions: They cannot usually take more than 1,000 full charges and discharges.

The third point is merely economic; but even if you had as much money as the Natural Resources Defense Coucil, you could not drive more than 20 to 40 miles before stopping to recharge the batteries, and even if you had as much time as an EPAcrat approving waste disposal, you would still miss the acceleration of a conventional car: Regular EV's take 10 to 20 seconds from 0 to 30 mph, and most of them do not go faster than 45 mph. (True, there are EV's that have gone more than 150 miles on a single charge, but they were driven at constant, low speeds, and are not typical of what is on the market.)

Hence there are no more than 3,000 EV's on US roads, almost all of them in experimental programs, in particular, in the test program run by the US Postal Service. In Britain, the leader of EV development, there are some 40,000 EV's on the road to take care of house-to-house deliveries, and in Britain that means not only the mail, but also the milk and other dairy products. In some places, EV's have been delivering the milk almost since the proverbial British milkhorse left the scene.



 • Energy and Civilization
 • TRANSPORTATION
 • WHAT'S RIGHT WITH IT
 • THE LETDOWN
 • THE FUTURE
 • OTHER POSSIBILITIES
 • OBSCENE OIL PROFITS
 • THE NEWSTWISTERS
 • DENIS THE MENACE
 • NUCLEAR NOTES
 • GOOD READING
Vol. 7, No. 6

Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
Volume: Volume 7
Issue/No.: Vol. 7, No. 6

Date: February 01, 1980 03:08 PM
Title: Energy and Civilization

Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
All rights reserved.