Lynching the oil companies used to be a national sport only a few years ago; it has now become the exclusive pastime of a power elite in and around the Carter administration, and of course, of the mass media, which have good reason to be appalled and indignant: ABC's profits on investment in 1978, for example, were 57.6643% more obscene than Exxon's, and 71.42857% more obscene than Mobil's. The fact is that the "windfall profits" tax is an excise tax which does not even depend on profit, whether windfall (whatever that is) or not; that the oil companies cannot sneeze without government permission, so that they are being punished by those whose orders they follow; that their return on investment is much smaller, and their market concentration negligible, in comparison with the media monopoly; that US government price fixing policy forces them to buy $40 spot oil for the DoE entitlement mix, and to sell $25 contractual oil abroad at whatever markup they can get, which means that the DoE makes the US taxpayer pay the difference to OPEC; that the oil companies could make more dollars by buying US government bonds than by drilling for oil; that their know-how, distribution net and technical facilities are a major national asset.
They are being punished for the vice of making profits, not rewarded, like Chrysler, for the virtue of botching things into bankrupcy.
On the other hand, it does not follow that every scapegoat must be lovable; and much of big oil stinks. That a Mobil vice president preaches free enterprise in newspaper ads and then goes campaigning for Crown Prince Kennedy is arguably a personal matter; but what when his chairman warns not to take off price controls too quickly? Or Atlantic Richfield's chairman clamors for more government planning? Or Sohio prostrates itself before Jerry Brown?
Perhaps if you kick somebody long enough, he finally becomes kickable.
|
|
Vol. 7, No. 6
Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive Volume: Volume 7 Issue/No.: Vol. 7, No. 6 Date: February 01, 1980 03:08 PM Title: Energy and Civilization
Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
|