Access to Energy

HOWEVER...

Now such a wallop of energy hitting a man (in a spot corresponding to the beam's cross-section) is not going to be very healthy; but the effect will not be essentially different, at incomparably greater expense, than that of a bullet shot from a rifle of Civil War vintage.

And it will do very little to tanks or other metal objects for a reason that is almost as old as warfare¾and here we refer to the great historical hoax that Archimedes set fire to Roman ships with mirrors concentrating sunlight on them. This fairy tale entered Western folklore in the 12th century, more than 1400 years after Archimedes' untimely death at the hands of some cultural antecedents of the Soviet army. But once a myth takes hold, it is hard to eradicate¾like the "near-catastrophe" of Three Mile Island.

One of several reasons why this story is recognizable as a hoax is that even with a laser, Archimedes could not have kept the point of incidence stationary on a ship rolling on the waves¾and it takes several seconds to set fire even to a stationary piece of paper with a lens focusing the sun on it.

Quite similarly, a laser beam can melt a hole through metal, provided it stays in the same spot for long enough to deliver the necessary energy, and delivers it faster than it can be carried away by heat conduction. The "long enough" is the difficulty that one might call the Archimedean headache; but there is now an aspirin for it¾the computer.

Computers, therefore, are the next ingredient of the death ray: they can guide the ray, and make it follow the motion of the target until it is incapacitated, whereupon they make the guidance system seek out the next target and destroy it.

Computers are the one area where the Soviets have evidently not yet caught up. (Remember that when the technology transfer buffs preach free trade with the USSR - see also France's decision on computers for the Siberian gas pipeline, p.3.)

But even with computers, one is still two long steps removed from a death ray.

[More on Archimedes: A History of Pi; details of the mirror hoax, "Archimedes and the burning mirrors of Syracuse" by D.L. Simms, Technology and Culture, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 1-24, January 1977.



 • The vermin in the coattails
 • DIRECTED ENERGY
 • HOWEVER...
 • THE MEDIUM
 • THE PACER
 • ... OR THE LACK OF IT
 • SOVIET GAS FOR EUROPE
 • THERE'S TOO MANY OF YOU OTHERS
 • STANDING UP TO THE SCAREMONGERS
Vol. 9, No. 4

Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
Volume: Issues
Issue/No.: Vol. 9, No. 4

Date: November 23, 2004 01:19 PM
Title: The vermin in the coattails

Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
All rights reserved.