It is no privilege of the Democrats to cater to the numerous and impressionable, nor is their policy matters of energy important compared with the life-or-death issues on which they will take a resolute stand this way, that way, or any other way provided only it will get them votes.
It is nevertheless instructive, as the hoopla, harangues and hypocrisy begin in San Francisco, to note the stand of the three Democratic contestants on some matters of energy; not because it is likely that any of them will get the chance to break their promises, but because it is an illustration of small time politics.
"The shadow of a devil
¾Diablo Canyon¾hangs over you," declaimed Walter Mondale as he wooed the sham-environmentalists in his audience. "We've had one close can. Don't let that disaster happen here."Was that close call the hydroelectric dam above the San Fernando Valley which cracked in the 1970 earthquake and would have killed tens of thousands within minutes if it had not been empty at the time? Did he mean this disaster that Diablo Canyon can prevent? No: he meant Three Mile Island, where the absence of casualties was not accidental, but where to this day one life is lost every week in the substitute power cycle, because politicians like Mondale keep Unit 1 closed. Whether he has the wits to see this is doubtful; what wits there were in the Carter-Mondale team appeared to be exhausted by Jimmy Carter's intellect.
But lack of information was not the problem with Gary Hart, whom readers may remember from his role in the TMI episode in March 1979. As the (then) chairman of the subcommittee for nuclear regulation, he had access to the confidential forecasts by an interagency team of specialists from the HEW, EPA and NRC. The expected number of deaths in an evacuation within a 20-mile radius (due to heart attacks of the elderly, traffic accidents, etc.) was 5.4, as against insignificant dangers if no evacuation took place. But what's five human lives when Hart can make political hay? He went on television, had himself billed as chairman of the senate subcommittee on nuclear power regulation, and announced that he would immediately evacuate his family if it lived there. (His family, as he must have known as chairman, could have halved its annual dose of radiation by moving from mile-high Denver to the neighborhood of the just disabled TMI reactor.) His willingness to sacrifice five human lives for his political career makes Hart something peculiar even among politicians
¾the ultimate type of peculiarity.And then there is the impostor who last March ranted against nuclear power with bulging eyes and hoarse voice at a TMI commemoration. If there was anything to commemorate, it was the fact that for the first time in human history more than 800 MW of power went out of control without hurting a living soul: by inherent safety, not sheer luck. But beyond that, most blacks
¾certainly the NAACP¾realize that economic advancement needs abundant energy, not playing second fiddle to the Sierra Clubbers in Beverly Hills. For all the blacks who can afford a $500,000 solar home like Amory Lovins and want to tax the poor to subsidize rich men's toys, this buddy of Castro and Arafat is the ideal candidate. The remainder will eventually realize that the present solar-energy policy (enacted under Carter and never repealed under Reagan) has the effect of building solar-heated country clubs in Westchester County from the taxes paid in Harlem; and that only an Uncle Tom would continue it.Now that's only the Democrats, and only their attitudes to some points of energy. But when government force is used ever less for defense against aggressors, and ever more for channeling the fruits of production to the vociferous and influential, then the winning candidate is the one who promises to cater to the most numerous and most impressionable.
So when you see these three specimen with heads held high, mouths closed in resolute determination, and hands piously on their hearts, remember these are the patriots who will bring you prosperity, justice, and above all, peace.
|
|
Vol. 11, No. 11
Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive Volume: Issues Issue/No.: Vol. 11, No. 11 Date: November 29, 2004 12:18 PM (For actual publication date see newsletter.) Title: Small-time politics
Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
|