An argument against food irradiation that has not yet been heard explicitly is that the rights of the trichina worm are being violated. But the following extract from a reader's letter to Nature (9 Feb 84) comes pretty close:
"...to retain absolute natural rights for our own species while withholding them from other species is, in my view, antideluvian
¾or, to be more accurate, pre-Darwinian. What distinguishes this viewpoint from the ethnocentricity of those tribes whose members think that they are the only humans and that people of neighboring tribes can be slaughtered like pigs?"The animal-righters share a basic principle with the sham-environmentalists and peaceniks: they appeal to a noble sentiment (love of animals, a clean environment, peace) in order to trap their credulous followers into a totally different agenda
¾in this case, anti-science and de-industrialization. They are also reminiscent of the "Earth First!" thugs in that their methods of peaceful reasoning include spray-paint vandalism, window smashing and laboratory destruction. Although they were particularly active before the 1984 California Animals' Rights Initiative (which was mercifully defeated), misguided parrots keep taking up their cry.Among them is Dear Abby, to whom AtE reader Ralph Rohweder of Mt.
Vernon, Va., sent a letter including the following:
"I assume you will be consistent in your opposition to the use of living animals for medical tests.
"You will use no medicines at all because their biological effects
¾ both good and bad¾have been determined through experiments on animals. You will choose to die rather than accept surgery or a life-threatening condition because not only is most surgical technique the result of animal research, but all anesthetics came from animal research. You will have to avoid many foods because much of what is known about safe preservation of food resulted from tests with living organisms. And of course you will have to forego veterinary care for your pets, because veterinary know-how is clearly and directly the result of animal research."But let's face it, the trichina worm has few friends even among the animals-righters, as does the louse or the cholera bacillus. The reason for this inconsistency has nothing to do with the harm these species do to humans (conservationists do, after all, protect tigers, alligators and grizzly bears). What makes these creatures friendless is that unlike guinea pigs or monkeys, but very much like half a million drowned Boat People, they die unseen. And what motivates the laboratory-trashing ecofreaks is not love of animals (let alone people), but fear that their sheltered sensibilities might be shaken out of their stupor.
|
|
Vol. 14, No. 1
Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive Volume: Issues Issue/No.: Vol. 14, No. 1 Date: November 29, 2004 04:51 PM Title: Beyond oil and metals
Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
|