Access to Energy

DUMB AND SMART

Fort Freedom, no matter how impressive, is completely dumb. There is not one decision it takes that I have not pre-programmed into it. If you type an H (in the Courtyard), it goes to the Historical Archives, if you type "%" it says "not an option," if the power goes off, it starts itself again when the power goes on. It anticipates all possible eventualities¾I hope, and if I have overlooked one, it will be revealed as totally dumb: it will just sit there doing nothing.

To the contrary, a program to play chess or checkers does not foresee every possible move; it is programmed to make its own deci-sions by following certain principles (as well as using its past ex-perience). In my opinion, a new era of mankind dawned (but isn't here yet) on the day, back in the early days of AI, when a program to play checkers beat its own programmer.

The speed, reliability and memory of computers is certainly im-pressive, but in principle no more than the speed of a bullet or the force of a crane, for all of these man-made machines surpass man's corresponding ability. But a machine that outdoes man not in some physical property, but outwits him, is surely something entirely new.

Do not confuse intelligence with efficiency. Suppose I want to know the biggest number under 10,000 that is divisible by 51 (without remainder). Then a repugnantly stupid program would give instructions to look for the remainder in 1/51, then give new instructions to try it with 2/52, and so forth to 10,000/51. If instead I give not 10,000 instructions, but a single set of instructions to try it with 1/51 and how to repeat the procedure for every integer up to 10,000, then I have only used shorthand for the same program: it is more efficient (shorter) to write, but equally dumb in execution.

On the other hand, if you use my head and see that the number must lie between 10,000 and 10,000 minus 51, you can write a more efficient program that is much shorter both for writing and in ex-ecution¾but it's still as dumb as it was, for the intelligence of re-ducing it came out of your head,



 • The new venality
 • INTELLIGENCE
 • DUMB AND SMART
 • . . . AND VERY DUMB
 • EMPIRICAL KNOWLEDGE
 • SOUTH AFRICAN SANCTIONS ARE WORKING
 • NUCLEAR NOTES
 • GOOD READING
Vol. 16, No. 1

Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
Volume: Issues
Issue/No.: Vol. 16, No. 1

Date: December 01, 2004 01:51 PM
Title: The new venality

Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
All rights reserved.