Access to Energy

MORBUS BRODEURlCUS

As I have said before, I am not a doctor and cannot say whether magnetic fields have any health effects on the human body (a diag-nosis, incidentally, identical with that by the most illustrious doctors of the century). What I can say is that the magnetic fields in a home are generally larger than those from power lines, even if they are in the vicinity, so anybody worried about the cancer and other scares put out by Brodeur the eco-porneur need only ask his utility to dis-connect his household.

Brodeur's collections of anecdotal hunches void of any observa-tions with control experiments whatsoever continue to pollute the press, but the great physician (with an M.D. from The New Yorker) has now advanced from diagnostics to therapy in an article pub-lished by Board Room Reports. That says more about a sleazy publication willing to publish such garbage than about any dangers from mag-netic fields, and if you feel unbearable hatred toward your boss, why don't you honor him with a gift subscription? A sample of Brodeur's therapeutic prowess:

"Be sure to unplug the device. Don't just turn it off. No~e: An unheated waterbed will get very cold." (That settles the 1990 Nobel Prize for physics.)

But if the danger of cancer existed, asks an interviewer, a lot of children would have got cancer from watching television. To which he answers "For proof that dangerously high magnetic fields are given off by VDTs [computer terminals], see the July 1990 of Mac-world. "

Indeed, look it up to see what their source is. None other than the illustrious physician, physicist and bibliographer Brodeur himself (who is also an illustrious lawyer, for he has not answered the question.)

For people who prefer experts to eco-pornographers I recom-mend the draft report "Electric and magnetic fields: measurements and possible effects on human health. What we know and what we don't know in 1990", by four M.D.s of the Special Epidemiological Studies Program, Calif. Dept. of Health services, 2151 Berkeley Way/#704, Berkeley, CA 94704. [I do not know how easy it is to get the report; the tel.no. is 415-540-2916]. This is a detailed, readably written report for the public, whose essential conclusion is might be rendered as "we have not uncovered anything conclusive, but we are still trying hard."

I have previously written that I cannot say anything about eye strain and other forms of stress. But as Howard Hayden, professor of physics at the U. of Conn. has recently told me, ultrasound is a possible irritant. Ultrasound is normal sound, but too high to hear, and it may give people headaches or otherwise irritate them: there are some who cannot stay long in an art exhibition if the security system uses ultrasound, and some teaching assistants get headaches (and even red ears) after demonstrating ultrasound equipment in class.

Young people normally hear up to a pitch of about 18 kHz (kilohertz); with age the limit usually goes down to about 15 kHz. Sound, plain or ultra, is formed by waves of pressure in the air (or other medium) and has nothing to do with electromagnetic radia-tion. The frequency of lines ("horizontal sweep frequency") in TV and other terminals is usually close to 18 kHz, and though this is the frequency of a current or voltage, there can be coupling to a mechanical source that gives rise to sound¾for example, magnetic materials may be "excited" by currents at that frequency to oscil-late in the manner of a tuning fork or other sound source, very weakly of course, and for most people inaudibly. It is not impos-sible that this continuous sound emitted by some VDTs, though inaudible, stresses some people and gives them headaches or makes them feel queasy¾though that is not exactly cancer.

But above all, there is the psychosomatic connection that if you think VDTs ought to give you a headache, then you will actually get one¾in a sort of negative placebo effect. So it is my guess that by far the greatest culprit of any health effects near VDTs is Brodeur himself. The unfailing remedy for morbus brodeuricus is a little knowledge and common sense.



 • Saddam's American Assistants
 • URANIUM: DON'T LEAVE IT IN THE GROUND!
 • BUT THERE'S MORE
 • THE PLANET'S TERMINAL CONDITION
 • MORBUS BRODEURlCUS
 • ECHOES AND UPDATES
 • TWO FROM THE SEWER . . .
 • . . . AND ONE FROM THE TOP DRAWER
 • GOOD READING
Vol. 18, No. 2

Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
Volume: Issues
Issue/No.: Vol. 18, No. 2

Date: December 01, 2004 03:57 PM (For actual publication date see newsletter.)
Title: Saddam's American Assistants

Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
All rights reserved.