Access to Energy

MAGLEV REVISITED

Magnetic levitation or Maglev [AtE Mar 74, Jan 86, May 88] is applied to wheelless trains floating above a track at speeds of more than 300 mph. The upward force is provided by superconducting magnets which repel the train from the guiding rails (or use a hook-like structure which is attracted upwards toward them); the forward force is furnished by a running field preceding the train, much like a motor whose poles and armature are laid out flat rather than cylindrically.

Japan, one of the serious contenders for leadership in this type of mass transportation, suffered a setback on 10/3/91, when a 70-ft maglev train caught fire on one of the Japanese experimental tracks. It had little enough to do with maglev technology, for what caught fire was one of the rubber tires on which the train rolls at low speeds before coming to a stop or taking off. The tire simply went flat and caught fire by friction. However, as at TMI and in the very recent Chernobyl accident (one of the remaining units had a fire in the machine room, not the reactor), such mishaps discredit the principal technology¾irrationally, but indisputably.

The accident happened only a week before the Office of Tech-nology Assessment (a congressional institution, but nevertheless often very good) issued its report "New Ways: tiltrotor aircraft and magnetically levitated vehicles," aimed primarily at fast transpor-tation between cities and their airports and in crowded urban cor-ridors. The US has had maglev trains on experimental tracks for 10 years and they are now technically feasible; but their commercial realization is unlikely for some 10 more years due to difficulty in financing, the absence of safety regulations, and local community objections.

Unlike maglev, where Germany and Japan appear to be the leaders, the US has a lead of about 5-year in another technology that could compete with maglev, tiltrotor aircraft. Their engines can be swiveled so that the plane of propeller rotation is either ver-tical or horizontal. Turning the engines upwards, the plane can take off vertically like a helicopter, and turning them forward it be-comes a regular forward-thrust airplane.

Though the report naturally pushes federal financing and big government, it is well illustrated and its technical parts are quite readable and very informative.

[More: "Maglev burns out in Japan," Nature 10/17,"New Ways: tiltrotor aircraft and magnetically levitated vehicles," $3.75 from Govt. Printg. Off., Washington, DC 20402; stock no. 052-003-01256-1.]



 • Without Malice Aforethought
 • OUR NEAREST STAR
 • THE NEWS FROM DENMARK
 • REILLY RIDES AGAIN
 • BILLY BOY'S BUNK BY THE BARREL
 • MAGLEV REVISITED
 • ECHOES AND UPDATES
 • STARK RAVING MAD
 • GOOD READING
Vol. 19, No. 4

Newsletter: Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
Volume: Volume 19
Issue/No.: Vol. 19, No. 4

Date: December 01, 1991 09:47 AM
Title: Without Malice Aforethought

Copyright © 2004 - Access to Energy Newsletter Archive
All rights reserved.